Current Issue:
1. Visibility Obstruction: The strike zone fades out during the pitcher's motion as seen in the video below which can obscure the visual cue needed for accurate pitch judgement, potentially making it harder for players to make precise swings.
2. Inconsistent Gameplay: The fading effect may create inconsistency in gameplay, as players who rely heavily on the strike zone for timing and accuracy may find their performance affected unpredictably.
3. Reduced Accessibility: For players who prefer a more straightforward visual aid or who struggle with the fading effect, this design choice can limit accessibility and reduce overall enjoyment, especially for those who may not be as familiar with real life pitching dynamics.
Why San Diego Studios might have chosen this approach:
San Diego Studios likely chose to have the strike zone fade out to enhance realism and immersion. By mimicking the uncertainty and dynamic nature of real-life baseball, where the strike zone isn't always clearly defined during a pitch, they aim to create a more authentic gameplay experience. This approach reflects the challenges players face in actual games, adding a layer of difficulty and engagement for those who appreciate a simulation of real-world conditions.
How can a Toggle Feature Improve User Experience?
From a user experience perspective, I believe the game would benefit from adding a toggle feature that allows players to keep the strike zone visible or hide it based on their preference. The customization would cater to different play styles, enhancing accessibility and overall enjoyment. It's a simple yet effective solution that aligns with user-centered design principles, offering more control to the player and potentially improving gameplay satisfaction.
My Approach:
My approach emphasizes giving users the ability to tailor their experience by introducing options to change the color of the strike zone, similar to the existing customization available with the PCI (Plate Coverage Indicator). By allowing players to adjust the strike zone's color to their preference, the game can better accommodate individual visual needs and preferences, ultimately enhancing visibility and comfort. This kind of customization empowers users to create an experience that aligns with their unique play style, increasing satisfaction and engagement with the game.
Takeaway:
The key takeaway from this analysis is the importance of balancing realism with usability in game design. While striving for authenticity can enhance immersion, it's crucial to ensure that the design choices do not hinder the player's ability to engage effectively with the game. By integrating features like a toggle for the strike zone, designers can maintain realism while also accommodating different play styles and improving overall user experience.
